According to TRREB, the average detached house sold in TRREB's C09 district, which covers Rosedale and Moore Park, went for $4,028,054 in October 2026. In October 2025 the average was $5,777,500. That is a drop of roughly 30% in the average over twelve months. In the same October 2026 report, TRREB's benchmark price for a typical C09 detached house was $3,397,800, down 2.90% from a year earlier.
The two figures come from the same board, the same district and the same month, and they disagree by about 27 percentage points. A buyer comparing Rosedale with Forest Hill, Lawrence Park or the Annex will see the first figure on every portal. The second figure is the better guide. A third figure, the share of the asking price that sellers actually received, says the most about what buying a Rosedale house is like this fall.
Seventeen houses make a small sample
The October average swung so much because the number of sales is small. TRREB counted 17 detached sales in C09 in October 2026, against 7 in October 2025. When a district records single-digit or low-double-digit sales in a month, one estate lot on a ravine or one modest semi-converted house can move the average by hundreds of thousands of dollars. The average reports which houses changed hands. It does not report what any particular house is now worth.
The month before October shows this most clearly. In September 2026, C09 recorded 6 detached sales at an average of $7,185,000 and a median of $5,650,000. One month later the average was $4,028,054 and the median $3,492,500. The average fell by about 44% from one month to the next, while the year-over-year benchmark for a typical C09 detached house was down 2.90% in October. September's few sales were simply weighted toward the top of the market, and October's larger group was spread further down it.
| C09 detached | Oct 2025 | Sept 2026 | Oct 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 7 | 6 | 17 |
| Average price | $5,777,500 | $7,185,000 | $4,028,054 |
| Median price | $4,900,000 | $5,650,000 | $3,492,500 |
| New listings | 25 | 38 | 18 |
| Active listings | 49 | 51 | 39 |
| Sale-to-list ratio | 91% | 93% | 93% |
| Average days listed | 35 | 40 | 25 |
The median moved a little less than the average, but it moved a long way too. With 6 or 17 observations, no single summary number can stand in for the whole street grid between the Rosedale Valley ravine and Moore Park. October is the latest complete month TRREB has published.
The benchmark is the steadier figure
TRREB also publishes an MLS Home Price Index benchmark for each district. In the October 2026 tables, the C09 detached benchmark was $3,397,800 in October 2026, down 2.90% year over year.
The useful comparison is with the rest of the city. The City of Toronto detached benchmark was $1,422,800 in October 2026, down 3.82% over the same twelve months. By the benchmark, Rosedale detached values fell less than the city's over the past year. The C09 composite benchmark, which blends all home types in the district, was $1,891,300, down 0.46%.
A buyer who has watched the portal average slide and expects Rosedale to be on sale should start from the benchmark. It describes a market that softened modestly and held up somewhat better than Toronto as a whole. That is a very different starting point for an offer than a 30% correction.
The 93% figure is where the negotiation happens
If the benchmark says how far values have moved, the sale-to-list ratio says how deals close. In October 2026, C09 detached houses sold for an average of 93% of their final asking price. That tied with C12, the district that takes in the Bridle Path, for the lowest ratio of any Toronto district that month. Detached houses across the City of Toronto sold at 97% of asking. In the east-end districts E01 and E02, detached houses sold at 106% and 104% of asking.
On a house listed at $4 million, a 93% outcome works out to $3.72 million, a gap of $280,000 between the asking price and the agreed price. Rosedale sellers are not waiting months to close that gap. C09 detached houses averaged 25 days on the market in October 2026, against 24 days for detached houses citywide. In Rosedale, the asking price is where the negotiation begins. The two sides settle the difference quickly, at about the same speed as the rest of the city, where detached houses close much nearer their asking price.
Twelve months ago the gap was wider and slower to close. In October 2025, C09 detached houses sold at 91% of asking after an average of 35 days. This October the discount was smaller, at 7% against 9%, and the time on market was ten days shorter. Those are signs of a market that has firmed slightly over the past year, even though the headline average suggests the opposite.
The discount also sits mainly in one type of property. C09 semi-detached houses sold at 98% of asking in an average of 12 days in October 2026. Across all home types the district came in at 95%. The room to negotiate is in the detached houses, which are also where asking prices are highest and comparable sales are fewest.
Supply tightened between September and October
The listing counts point the same way. New detached listings in C09 fell from 38 in September 2026 to 18 in October, and active listings fell from 51 to 39. Dividing active listings by monthly sales gives a rough measure of how long it would take to sell the current supply. By that measure, C09 detached inventory went from about eight and a half months in September to a little over two months in October.
One strong month does not make a trend. The year-over-year comparison holds up, though. October 2026 had more than twice as many detached sales as October 2025, from fewer active listings: 39 against 49. Dollar volume for C09 detached sales was about $68.5 million in October 2026, against about $40.4 million a year earlier. This was happening while TRREB reported GTA-wide sales down 7.9% year over year for October 2026. Rosedale's detached segment moved more houses this fall than last fall, while the region overall moved fewer.
How to use this when comparing neighbourhoods
For a buyer weighing Rosedale against other central neighbourhoods this fall, the October numbers lead to three working conclusions.
First, price Rosedale from the benchmark. A 2.90% annual decline in the C09 detached benchmark, set against 3.82% for the city, gives a realistic idea of where values sit. A falling portal average gives a misleading one.
Second, expect asking prices to come down in negotiation, and expect it to happen quickly. A 93% average outcome over 25 days means there is room, but sellers who are priced near the market are not left waiting. A buyer who comes back three weeks later hoping for a better price may find the house already sold.
Third, compare Rosedale with neighbourhoods on the same measures. The 93% ratio is shared with C12 and sits well below the citywide figure. Our look at Lawrence Park's over-asking sales earlier this year and our piece on why Bridle Path estates sell slowly show how much negotiating conditions differ between nearby postal codes. A buyer moving between Rosedale and those areas is moving between different ways of doing a deal as well as different price points.
Every Rosedale house is priced from its own lot, its own street and its own condition, and the district figures give context only for that conversation. The Rosedale neighbourhood page covers the streets themselves, and TRREB's full October 2026 Market Watch has every district table cited here.
If you are weighing a Rosedale house this season and want to see how a specific asking price compares with the C09 benchmark and recent outcomes on that street, Anita Springate-Renaud can go through those numbers with you, in confidence, before you make an offer. Let's connect.